Winding Down In Iraq Without Consequences

And so Obama completes another Bush Administration milestone. The formal withdrawal of American forces commences from Iraq — although the Obama Administration fought hard (and bungled negotiations) with the Iraqis to leave a residual force. A goal to which ‘serious’ people like Joe Lieberman and John McCain still cling.

Oddly, the Senators and CENTCOM may get their way even so. Iraqi domestic political opposition (which centered mostly about language in negotiations re legal jurisdiction over American troops and initiation of military activity) may require American troops to ‘leave’ before they are ‘invited’ back. So don’t be too surprised to see American contingents re-flow back to supplement the tens of thousands of contractors and other assorted flotsam and jetsam left behind. Like some kind of cruddy residue.

The ‘support our troops’ stickers in SUV windows are fewer now. The magnets tucked away. Many Americans possibly sense things are different because NCIS no longer features Iraq-related plots prominently. For several seasons now.

Those who lied the U.S. into war a war of aggression or continued to support those lies after exposure? They’ve collectively (nice word, that, no?) have paid little or no price. Many personalities are regulars on the cable TV circuit. Some churn out mind numbing books that like Speer and Posnan try to argue ‘they did not know’ (and weren’t there). It’s their good fortune that Iraq is already becoming the (second) ‘Forgotten War’.

Others are less fortunate. Some returning home will be shocked at the society they thought they were defending. Welcome to the 99%.

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS

Still Smells Like A Strategic Disaster . . . Can You Check?

As a result, starting next month, we will be able to remove 10,000 of our troops from Afghanistan by the end of this year, and we will bring home a total of 33,000 troops by next summer, fully recovering the surge I announced at West Point. After this initial reduction, our troops will continue coming home at a steady pace as Afghan Security forces move into the lead. Our mission will change from combat to support. By 2014, this process of transition will be complete, and the Afghan people will be responsible for their own security. We are starting this drawdown from a position of strength.

American media has to put Obama’s nonsense into a cognitive frame they understand: who’s up, who’s down. Thus the bogus attention paid to Petraeus vs. Biden. This was classic Boy King Goldilocks. Withdrawing the surge troops (assuming it happens) still leaves 70,000 in a strategic black hole. One of the most comical moments tonight was to behold Gergen’s phlegmatic outrage that Obama did not do everything Petraeus told him.

————-

Unlike Gergen, Zakaria etc. you wouldn’t be surprised that we thought the speech merely modest if not mediocre. Its trumphalism hollow to even the most casual observer. What to make of such absurdities as “We are starting this drawdown from a position of strength? Many cynics might opine that the Boy King began misleading with “Good evening”, but, as Richard Cheney once said, we are not one of them.

The alleged goals and victory conditions enunciated again tonight – a cohesive national Afghan government, a reliable Afghan military, a non-corrupt police, etc. are not only wholly historically anomalous and thus beyond our means, but nothing can be achieved by kinetic violence. Whether one campaign season, two campaign seasons or a dozen.

In that sense, Obama’s cynical Goldilock’s solution is imposition of crass political calculation in the face of strategic insanity. Whether he pulls 10,000 now, leaves them, or pulls any other fraction of 100,000. Leaving a large American army in Afghanistan further exposes U.S. logistics to an increasingly hostile Pakistan. And that’s the rub.

The only feasible ‘victory’ outcome in Afghanistan as enunciated by the Boy King requires not only combat in Afghanistan. Pakistan must be eliminated as sanctuary and sponsor. A joint occupation of “Afpak” is beyond U.S. means and even imagination. But it does mean that prosecuting the ‘war’ in Afghanistan is even more strategically bankrupt than the Southeast Asian unpleasantness.

For a while Pakistan thought it would emerge the ultimate winner together with its proxies seeking control of Afghanistan for strategic depth (if no longer branded ‘Taliban’). Until recently, that is. The arrest of a brigadier and the naval base raid merely the latest signs of a burgeoning who whom.

For the U.S., Obama in Afghanistan presents a double irony. The first? LBJ et al. were actually more sincere in their mistakes than this crowd. The second? The first passes unrecognized.

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS

This Would Not Be Happening If Warren Christopher Were Alive *

What does the Obama Convention offer? Not much.

Nothing on Guatanamo, illegal and unconstitutional torture, nothing about Russia beyond platitudes about Neocon solidarity with Georgian freedom-loving activities, nothing about NATO expansion, nothing about China, India beyond a roll call of rising powers, and so on.

No specifics about Iraq (and skipping Biden’s vote for the war, too). No talk about restoring the constitution or separation of powers from a rogue Imperial Regime in both domestic and foreign affairs. We did get a shout out to the Iranians. And a gloss over the Crowned One’s glaringly thin credentials for the job patently ‘above his pay grade’.

Biden is the attack dog? It wasn’t a Dukakis 1988 gig but no Ann Richards there either. And Joe, lose the French cuff links. (We’re partial to them now and then but not when we pretend to be a working class stiff hob nobbing with Tweety and Scrantonians — and we know the area very well personally). Democrats can’t seem to take their gloves off to save their lives.

If not Biden, who? If not now, when? Carville must be bouncing off walls. Land one. Hard. And keep going. Repeat exercise. Politics is a contact sport — ‘change’ notwithstanding.


We agree Biden at least rose above Mark Warner — who was an outstanding govenor — but eh. Biden’s effort couldn’t even rouse a captive audience ready for red meat. Who would have thought the Democrats could once again teeter on the edge of pulling defeat from the jaws of inevitable victory. Even the Crowned Prince’s ‘surprise’ visit was flat — choreographed to put him in that building briefly for optics. A last minute pirouette to prevent his sole participation being his ‘Party Rally’ in that bizarre Flavian Amphitheatre. One can only pray some idiot doesn’t unknowingly say, ‘Yo dog, wouldn’t a cathedral of light be tight? Suburban soccer moms would think it was like, down with a U2 show. Hectic for sure.’

The Big Dog still shows them how to draw distinctions with ease — something he tried to teach Kerry to no avail. He truly is he most gifted natural politician of this generation. We can’t expect that from the Crowned One tonight based on his rhetorical history. A surprise would be welcome.

Last night was the best for the Democrats so far — although HRC has been exemplary through out. If the Crowned One or David Axelrod doesn’t pay down her debt now (or at a more felicitous moment) in a significant way, they are truly men of little vision, honor or decency.

And as an aside, who precisely anointed the slightly bloated Luke Russert the spokesperson for the Millennials?

*Old joke from 1993 (and yes, we know he is still ambulatory).

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS

Surging To Afghanistan

Our old friend at Global Paradigms neatly lays out the trap Democrats set for themselves shifting war from Iraq to Afghanistan. One need only toss a cursory glance at the fate of the Soviet 40th Army and Gromov’s inglorious retreat across the Freedom Bridge (yes, yes we know, Milt, take another bow and send another memory fax to Langley).

Full circle back to Kipling.


[Read more...]

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS

Fears Of The Withdrawal Method, Performance Anxiety: The New Age Of Levitra Foreign Policy


________________________

Un homme: Est-ce que nous sommes fou?

Autre homme: Oh, mais la philosophie de Condi est plus intéressante que la philosophie existentialiste Obama et les 300! Ils veulent défaite! Nous serons là pour mille ans! Maliki est comme une jeune vierge attendant d’être séduit . . . Tu es d’accord, n’est-ce pas?

Homme: Quel crétin! Retourne à tes jeux fantastique . . .

Autre Homme: Hey, you sound French !

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS

The Bloody Crawl Home

No matter what Petraeus says today about one brigade coming out early next year or not, by September many if not most brigades will be pulling back to Kuwait and the long sail home.   The Army simply can’t sustain the surge without breaking, period.  Even Pace knows this.

Sometimes retreats are disasters, sometimes not. Few expect this one to be akin to those Great Historical calamities, at least in immediate terms — although a fighting retreat is not ruled out.

The long term implications may be as bad if not cataclysmic. Yet Bin Laden’s throw of the dice is that he can wave a red cape and keep the Warlord impaling himself and American power on the Iraqi Tree of Thorns. That Bin Laden’s speech echoed so many Democrat themes the perfect goad. How well our enemy understands us, how ignorant and unwise we.

A Democratic majority has not forced a withdrawal to the understandable bewilderment and rage of their base. Still, they stopped in no small way the larger danger posed by the Administration — the destruction of liberal democracy here at home. Not completely — as made clear by the FISA cave in. But better than the unified government. That, to the Stiftung was always the larger peril, the war merely the most obvious.

So don’t expect alot of comment here in the days and weeks ahead about Petreaus, the blahs over this or that, etc. It’s all smoke and mirrors to the Stiftung. Our troops are going to start coming home, Dear Reader, in 2008. One way or another.

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS

Re-Write Development Hell (Updated)

Sifting through box office wrecks, the hows and the whys, often can be instructive – and fun. And they can tell us much about ourselves and contemporary mores.

It used to be said, ‘read biography’. Today, an aging self-styled campus sage might advise a precocious undergrad to blow off History 301 (a). Kick back in the upper stacks ‘checking out franchise development and cross promotion’. He’d be right, too. Except the sage wouldn’t know the student already likely has started a multimedia company in his dorm room by now.

Oh, there are the obvious ones. We all have our favorite worsts: Waterworld, Ishtar, Heaven’s Gate, etc. Some threatened studios. Superman lately came close, too. Egos, budgets, bad scripts . . . perhaps the exhaustion of the American myth-telling reservoir. And some projects have lasting improbable impact beyond all immediate recognition. Syd Meade and Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner, being re-issued yet again, an example.

So all the way around, we’re not talking purely creative judgments. Sturgeon’s Law — 90% of everything is crap and all that. Crap sells. So what if the Warlord’s war plan was and is crap. That, too is besides the point. The irony of “You asked for the best you got the best” is not limited to bad garage bands.

_________________

We thought about this watching the Warlord’s VFW speech. It had a power-Vicodin vibe to it. True, he failed to deliver the knock-out Belushi line — “Did we give up when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor?” But there were a moments when it seemed touch and go.

Think of the VFW gig as a preview of the war’s “Direct To Video Marketing” phase. There are only two rungs lower: Pay-Per-View and the “New, Unrated Cut”. The old high brow marketing cliches are over and done. Mr. Smith Goes To Washington? Out. Green Berets? Fini. A May-December romance? Non. It’s a buddy comedy, it’s a shoot-em up? Terminated. Now, they’re not even trying, just pouring the nihilism syrup straight from the tap.

Wednesday’s pre-emptive ‘Stab-in-the-Back’ meme is politically a marketing winner. The base comes back. All can blame Democrats for everything. Meanwhile, the Neocons still see a chance to burn out American power and lives in pursuit of their agenda for the Realm, and Pat and the others relive the trauma of 74-75.

John Warner’s gentle defection is overplayed — not even within the same solar system as Goldwater’s visit to Nixon. Warner even points to the blame on Maliki. Still, the Warlord’s Script Doctors screwed up — everyone needs to get the new green re-write pages before going live. Pace this morning spoke with the old yellow pages which left room for a smidgeon of his integrity — by the afternoon he too was back on the new green re-write. It doesn’t matter. Everyone knows Pace is correct. This expedition is overextended and exhausted.

Many Hollywood screenwriters use computer screen writing assistants to create templates and formulaic story lines, you know — (a) introduction; (b) rising tension; (c) complication; (d) resolution; (e) epilogue, character arcs, complications, etc. Not a few refuse to accept scripts unless already in these computerized formats. Does a theater goer care? That they’ve seen the same basic movie hundreds of times? Not if all is done well.

Same with wars. There are certain basic templates, rules and realities. Must haves that the public never really thinks about. And when they do, it usually is in a superficial pundit way. What the actual lifecycle costs to acquire, train, maintain, support and deploy, let alone replenish Human Capital in the Force is an gigantic unknown reality.

The realities of flowing these forces in or out of a theater of operation also unknown — which is why Time magazine can print such Pentagon-spun numbers so credulously. And once in theater, the deployment costs and vulnerabilities for POL (petroleum, oil, lubricants) crazed platforms and logistics and so on. “Loggies” are a breed apart and their wizardry close to the cosmic, but woe be to the OSD or NSC pinhead who ignores their professional judgments.

The first noxious phrase pundits tosses around was a year ago — “the army is breaking” etc. They pick these phrases from sneezing and shaking hands in Green Rooms. Next it was “clear and hold”, followed by the “Anbar Bargain”. All empty words to empty heads. The latest empty phrase being batted around? “Only one brigade can come out in a month at best”.

It’s really entertaining. Imagine a Suit showing up from the Studio on a set wracked by labor strife, actors incapacitated by drugs, rival studio crews sabotaging equipment, a spineless director, empty funds and angry town locals threatening a mass riot, all over a flooded sound stage. The Suit struts in, views the situation says “I see signs of progress, but I am not feeling the creativity, people!” and then turning on heel gets back in the Bentley for lunch. Perhaps a call on the car cell phone bitching that the Producer is too weak. Not too far off, eh?

As we’ve written several times, tt will take 8-10 years to reconstitute the Force even if we begin pulling out NOW. This is not to say the choices are only binary complete “withdraw” or “stay in Warlord land”. Withdrawals can be managed to allow political forces in Iraq to seek their own level of balancing violence. Even with some residual strategic core force in place.

The Warlord shot his wad years ago. And we can not maintain the surge. Period. So the only question is on what basis the withdrawal occurs and what future U.S. posture remains in Iraq (and under what misrepresentations). The pay-per-view marketing of this loser and the unrated cut will be Buchanan in his most orgiastic bliss, mark these words. The true horror of what the Warlord has wrought has yet to shoved into America’s celubutante-besotted eyes. But it will be.

Btw, also bad news for Israel Cheney Will Attack Iran Before 2008 gang we think. Even their Script Doctors ain’t that bad. Strategic withdrawals are among the most difficult achievements. In the best of circumstances. A sufficiently pissed off Iran could make the American withdrawal fall closer to Chosin or worse. Despite Kaplan’s effort to stroke some B2-porn for the Neocons.

The Stiftung’s sense of play at the moment? The Warlord’s gotterdammerung psychic imagery will continue but we’ll see basic withdrawals begin in ’08 simply to preserve the structural viability of the Force. Masking the cognitive dissonance will be a virulent and divisive direct-to-video “enemies” campaign possibly surpassing 2004.

The wild card? How openly and aggressively Iran wants to celebrate its strategic victory. Or push onwards. Absent a true Iranian provocation, we still don’t see the Realm going back into Lebanon before Fall ’08. YMMV.

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS